Senate Finance Committee's version of the 'big, beautiful bill' sets up a potential clash with the House

[ad_1] The Senate Finance Committee unveiled its proposed modifications to the Home-passed model of President Donald Trump's "massive, lovely invoice" on Monday evening, which may put the 2 chambers on a collision course.

The Senate proposal displays an extension of the Trump 2017 tax cuts, a debt restrict improve to keep away from a possible default later this summer season and cuts to Medicaid.

Senators have been warned by Home leaders to make minimal modifications to the invoice to make sure it may possibly cross, given the razor-thin margin within the decrease chamber. There's additionally numerous senators who've conditioned their assist for this invoice on sure proposals within the Senate model of the invoice.

Senate Republicans had been assembly Monday evening behind closed doorways to go over the proposal.

The Capitol is seen in Washington, June 9, 2025.

J. Scott Applewhite/AP

Listed here are potential sticking factors:

State and native taxes cap The Senate laws as drafted would hold the cap on state and native tax (SALT) deductions at $10,000 a 12 months, whereas the Home invoice presents deductions as much as $40,000 per 12 months for these making lower than $500,000 yearly.

Some Home Republicans have mentioned they are going to vote no on the ultimate invoice if the deduction is any decrease than the $40,000 they painstakingly negotiated.

Senators have mentioned the $10,000 cap is at present only a placeholder, is just not finalized, and continues to be being negotiated. Together with a worth permits the nonpartisan Congressional Price range Workplace to start scoring the invoice, however senators say the rating could possibly be modified because the SALT cap modifications.

“I referred to as the SALT guys and mentioned, ’Hey, do not go nuclear on us’,” mentioned GOP Sen. Markwayne Mullin, who has been a key mediator between the Home and Senate. “We needed to put one thing there as a result of we're nonetheless negotiating backwards and forwards.”

Senate Majority Chief John Thune responds to a query from the information media as he walks to his workplace within the Capitol in Washington, June 5, 2025.

Shawn Thew/EPA-EFE/Shutterstock

Medicaid Just like the Home’s model, the Senate invoice implements work necessities on Medicaid for “in a position bodied adults who're selecting to not work and don't have dependent kids or aged mother and father of their care.”

It additionally will increase the frequency of eligibility verifications for able-bodied adults.

In a position-bodied adults with out dependents can work, take part in a piece coaching program, enroll at school, or volunteer for 20 hours per week with a purpose to obtain taxpayer-subsidized Medicaid protection.

It additionally ends taxpayer-funded Medicaid funds for abortion companies and gender transition procedures and ensures immigrants missing everlasting authorized standing don't obtain Medicaid advantages.

The largest distinction between the Home and Senate plans to scale back “waste, fraud, and abuse” in Medicaid contain the supplier tax, a state-imposed tax on well being care suppliers used primarily used to assist finance state Medicaid packages. Starting in 2027, the Senate laws would decrease well being care supplier taxes in states that selected to increase Medicaid to three.5%, down from 6% within the Home invoice, which suggests the burden on states to fund Medicaid could possibly be increased underneath the Senate’s model.

Taxes The Senate’s model completely extends the Trump 2017 tax cuts, one thing Senate Republicans say is crucial for companies and households seeking to plan for the longer term.

It additionally consists of no tax on ideas and no tax on time beyond regulation, a key Trump precedence. The invoice permits for deductions of as much as $25,000 in certified ideas, and deductions of as much as $12,500 in time beyond regulation. In the meantime, the Home’s model has no specific cap on ideas and time beyond regulation deductions.

The Senate’s invoice would additionally provide seniors a brand new $6,000 tax deduction -- extra beneficiant than the $4,000 deduction within the Home model.

It will additionally make everlasting varied enterprise and different tax incentives, together with expensing of investments in gear and analysis and growth.

Speaker of the Home Mike Johnson talks about his discussions with Elon Musk this week as he meets with reporters to debate work on President Donald Trump's invoice of tax breaks and spending cuts, on the Capitol in Washington, June 4, 2025.

J. Scott Applewhite/AP

Youngster tax credit score The Senate invoice pares again the kid tax credit score from $2,500 within the Home model to $2,200 per youngster. Just like the Home, it excludes households with no earnings.

The invoice additionally establishes financial savings accounts for newborns, just like the Home invoice.

Debt restrict The Senate package deal features a $5 trillion hike to the federal debt restrict, increased than the Home’s $4 trillion. Congress should act earlier than early fall to lift the debt restrict or danger default.

Republican Sen. Rand Paul has made clear he gained’t assist a package deal with a debt restrict improve. The inclusion of this provision means Republicans will possible lose his vote.

Phasing out of IRA tax credit The Senate model phases out photo voltaic vitality tax credit that had been a part of the Inflation Discount Act at a slower price than the Home model by permitting extra tasks to entry the credit earlier than they finish.

The Senate invoice additionally eliminates a whole bunch of billions of {dollars} of IRA subsidies, reminiscent of instantly ending the electrical car tax credit score and its “lease loophole,” just like the Home invoice.