Mayor Adams is bringing the tax lien sale back. Here’s how to get your property off the list

[ad_1] Should you’re an proprietor who has fallen behind in your payments for property taxes, water, sewer, or for emergency repairs, otherwise you’re a renter who lives in a constructing the place the proprietor is delinquent on the identical fees, the clock is ticking.

For the primary time since 2021, Mayor Eric Adams is gearing as much as maintain a tax lien sale, a 1996 creation of the Giuliani administration that outsources the gathering of unpaid property taxes and different housing payments. The sale allows house owners' money owed to be bought to personal buyers who tack on excessive curiosity and costs and go after you for the inflated quantity. If you don't pay, you'll be able to finally lose your property in a foreclosures public sale.

[Editor's note: A previous version of this article ran in March 2025. We are presenting it again in case you missed it.]

As of late March, 21,372 residential properties citywide had been on the checklist—that’s down from the 90-day checklist of 24,017 for properties in Class 1 (one- to three-unit homes) and Class 2 (co-op, condominium and rental buildings with four-plus models).

Housing advocates stated it’s essential for house owners on the checklist to behave earlier than their liens are bought. Warning notices are despatched within the mail 90, 60, 30, and 10 days earlier than the sale to inform house owners that if payments will not be paid, the debt will likely be bought to a non-public belief.

“We see lots of people on the lien sale checklist who shouldn’t be there,” stated Rachel Geballe, a supervising legal professional with the Neighborhood Financial Justice Undertaking of Authorized Companies NYC’s Brooklyn workplace. These could also be house owners who're entitled to an exemption as a result of they're a senior, veteran, or have a incapacity.

Homeowners can lose their exemptions “as a result of it's important to recertify they usually battle with paperwork. Many who come to us are eligible to be eliminated, however lots has to occur to get off the checklist,” Geballe stated.

How the lien sale operates The sale course of entails the Metropolis of New York pooling eligible liens and transferring possession to a belief; the belief (whose sole beneficiary is NYC) then makes use of invoice collectors to go after the money owed. The belief makes use of funds raised from bond gross sales to buyers to purchase the town’s liens at a reduction. Previously the low cost has been about 72 cents on the greenback, in line with a 2024 report from Middle for NYC Neighborhoods.

“By transferring the possession of its liens to a belief through a bulk sale, the bonds used to buy the liens are extra interesting to buyers, however that comes on the expense of oversight and accountability to bizarre New Yorkers,” the report famous. “This method was initially put into place to avoid the town’s debt restrict issues and is not related immediately, but nonetheless impression New York Metropolis’s most susceptible householders.”

Professional Tip Professional Tip: Wish to see the general public data of your constructing in a single unified report? Take a look at the Brick Report, our background test on any handle in New York Metropolis.

Why is the tax lien sale problematic? As soon as a tax lien is bought, a third-party assortment company can add charges and annual curiosity of as much as 18 %, compounded day by day. Meaning house owners who face liens can fall even farther behind. Subsequent the tax lien belief can begin a foreclosures motion; if it wins it could public sale the property to the very best bidder.

The tax lien sale has been proven to disproportionately impression house owners in communities of coloration and lower-income communities.

A report by the Coalition for Reasonably priced Properties discovered practically two-thirds of the lien gross sales bought within the 2021 sale had been in areas the place over half of householders recognized as non-white or Hispanic. Over one-fourth of the lien gross sales had been in areas the place house owners reported incomes of lower than $75,000.

Caption

A Division of Finance tax lien sale notification.

Unaware they're on the checklist Some house owners is probably not conscious they're on the tax lien sale checklist, stated Kevin Wolfe, deputy director of advocacy and public affairs at Middle for NYC Neighborhoods. That’s as a result of that is the primary time the sale is being held for the reason that pandemic, and house owners who obtained a discover within the mail could not perceive its significance, he stated. (The lien sale was paused in 2020.)

A disproportionate variety of small house owners are represented on the checklist, 42 %, despite the fact that that quantity displays 20 % of whole buildings, Wolfe stated.

He stated house owners on the checklist sometimes have paid off a mortgage or have a reverse mortgage and are sometimes seniors—or their heirs.

“They’re not used to receiving notices from the town,” he stated.

When liens are issued Homeowners who're behind on their property taxes, water payments, or emergency restore payments—for instance if tenants lacked warmth and the town changed the boiler—will be placed on the checklist.

Based on Middle for NYC Neighborhoods, for one-family homes, a tax lien will be bought if an proprietor has sustained a debt of not less than $5,000 for over three years. Should you solely owe water/sewer fees, however not property taxes, the town can't promote a lien in your property; nonetheless, DEP could terminate your water/sewer service if the fees stay delinquent.

For 2- to three-family houses, condominium and co-op buildings, a tax lien will be bought if an proprietor has sustained a debt of not less than $5,000 and people fees are three years overdue. A water or sewer lien of not less than $3,000 may also be bought if these fees are one 12 months overdue.

How one can get off the tax lien sale checklist The Abolish the NYC Lien Sale Coalition, a bunch of 10 housing advocacy teams and neighborhood land trusts, is sounding the alarm concerning the harms perpetuated by tax lien sale and a number of choices that house owners can use to take away themselves from the tax lien sale checklist. The group is holding neighborhood briefings to get the phrase out; the subsequent one is scheduled for April third at 6 p.m.

The coalition was profitable in getting legislative reforms handed within the Metropolis Council final 12 months to scale back the checklist. For instance, households that make lower than $107,300 in 2025 can now use the Straightforward Exit kind to have the property faraway from the lien sale 3 times in 36 months.

Different new choices embrace deferring metropolis debt or making income-based funds by way of Property Tax and Curiosity Deferral Packages (PT AID) in addition to the senior citizen householders exemption (SCHE), disabled householders exemption (DHE), veterans exemption, or not-for-profit exemption.

Finally, the coalition needs the lien sale to be abolished.

“We’ve been shrinking the lien sale. My hope is that the town thinks finally that it’s not value it, however I’m not holding my breath,” stated Paula Segal, senior employees legal professional within the Equitable Neighborhoods observe at TakeRoot Justice, throughout a latest neighborhood presentation.

In a cellphone dialog with Brick, Segal famous that Mayor Adams was bringing again the lien sale after 4 years, despite the fact that the town may have created a brand new system for debt assortment as an alternative of outsourcing the method once more and earning money for buyers. His finances workplace estimates bringing in $80 million every year over the subsequent 4 years from the lien sale.

“Peanuts,” Segal stated.

Throughout a Metropolis Council listening to in June on a invoice to implement reforms to the tax lien sale, Metropolis Council member Justin L. Brannan famous, “the Council has been and stays keen to let authorization for the lien sale expire reasonably than gather funds on the expense of driving foreclosures and homelessness amongst our most susceptible.”

‘Telephone guide for speculators’ One change Segal wish to see is to finish the general public launch of the lien checklist, which she referred to as a “cellphone guide for speculators.”

That is as a result of it readily identifies susceptible and determined house owners to con artists. Intro 783-2024 is a Metropolis Council invoice that might file debt with out a want for the lien sale and exchange the general public lien checklist with particular person recordings in ACRIS, the town's property database.

To Geballe, “it’s one of many worst issues concerning the lien sale—publishing the names of everybody who's behind on their payments.” She advises house owners who're going through liens that they're going to get loads of calls and that they need to solely settle for assist from trusted sources.

“Any provide of assist in alternate for cash is a rip-off,” she stated. In 2024, $2 million a 12 months in public funding was put aside for outreach and free authorized counseling for house owners and tenants affected by the lien sale by way of the Middle for NYC Neighborhoods.

There are quite a few methods off the lien checklist, and getting the appropriate assist could make a essential distinction.

Geballe stated she had an aged shopper who was additionally blind and had fallen behind on funds. As a substitute of being given an exemption, she had been put in a fee program she couldn’t afford.

She was on her strategy to dropping her property, however a authorized companies legal professional was capable of straighten issues with the Division of Finance in time and get the sale of her lien out of foreclosures, which saved her property.

What it is best to do in the event you’re a renter Renters may also be displaced by the lien sale. This state of affairs sometimes entails landlords who gather rents however don't pay their payments and ignore fines—they're betting on promoting for a big sum—they usually find yourself on the lien sale checklist

A brand new reform requires NYC’s Division of Housing Preservation and Improvement to do direct outreach to tenants in buildings which have landed on the lien checklist.

As well as, rental buildings which might be in misery are presupposed to be taken out of the lien sale. If there are issues in your rental constructing, contact HPD by way of 311 to file a criticism. This can assist the town flag your constructing.

The coalition is pushing for laws that might enact a metropolis foreclosures program to guard tenants in rental buildings with negligent landlords by changing the landlords and creating co-op conversion alternatives.

Backside line Should you obtained a lien discover within the mail, do not ignore it. You'll be able to:1) Pay what you owe. For property taxes and emergency restore fees, go to CityPay. For water or sewer fees, go to DEP's web site.2) Get on a fee plan. There are three choices: Normal fee plan for all property house owners, no matter age or earnings; PT AID fee plan in the event you earn $107,300 or much less per 12 months and meet different necessities, or PT AID Circuit Breaker fee plan in the event you meet the earnings cap above and your property tax invoice is greater than 10 % of your earnings and your property’s assessed worth is $250,000 or much less. In case you are accepted for considered one of these plans, you might also be eligible to pay a lowered rate of interest.3) Apply for an exemption: senior citizen householders exemption (SCHE), disabled householders exemption (DHE), veterans exemption, or a not-for-profit exemption.4) Apply for an Straightforward Exit.5) File an emergency restore certification.